Champions by season
- 2025-26Harborough Town2nd Spalding United
- 2024-25Bedford Town2nd Kettering Town
- 2023-24Needham Market2nd AFC Telford United
- 2022-23Tamworth2nd Coalville Town
- 2021-22Banbury United2nd Peterborough Sports
- 2020-21Coalville Town2nd Needham Market
- 2019-20Peterborough Sports2nd Tamworth
- 2018-19Kettering Town2nd King's Lynn Town
- 2017-18Hereford FC2nd King's Lynn Town
- 2016-17Chippenham Town2nd Leamington
- 2015-16Poole Town2nd Redditch United
- 2014-15Corby Town2nd Poole Town
- 2013-14Hemel Hempstead Town2nd Chesham United
- 2012-13Leamington2nd Stourbridge
- 2011-12Brackley Town2nd Oxford City
- 2010-11Truro City2nd Hednesford Town
- 2009-10Farnborough2nd Nuneaton Town
- 2008-09Corby Town2nd Farnborough
- 2007-08King's Lynn Town2nd Team Bath (E, R)
- 2006-07Bath City2nd Team Bath (E, R)
- 2005-06Salisbury City2nd Bath City
- 2004-05Histon2nd Chippenham Town
- 2003-04Crawley Town2nd Weymouth
- 2002-03Tamworth2nd Stafford Rangers
- 2001-02Kettering Town2nd Tamworth
- 2000-01Margate2nd Burton Albion
Most titles
Sources: Wikipedia, API-Football