Champions by season
- 2025-26Bromley2nd Cambridge United
- 2024-25Doncaster Rovers2nd Port Vale
- 2023-24Stockport County2nd Wrexham
- 2022-23Leyton Orient2nd Stevenage
- 2021-22Forest Green Rovers2nd Exeter City
- 2020-21Cheltenham Town2nd Cambridge United
- 2019-20Swindon Town2nd Crewe
- 2018-19Lincoln City2nd Bury FC
- 2017-18Accrington Stanley2nd Luton Town
- 2016-17Portsmouth2nd Plymouth Argyle
- 2015-16Northampton Town2nd Oxford United
- 2014-15Burton Albion2nd Shrewsbury Town
- 2013-14Chesterfield2nd Scunthorpe United
- 2012-13Gillingham2nd Rotherham United
- 2011-12Swindon Town2nd Shrewsbury Town
- 2010-11Chesterfield2nd Bury FC
- 2009-10Notts County2nd Bournemouth
- 2008-09Brentford2nd Exeter City
- 2007-08Milton Keynes Dons2nd Peterborough United
- 2006-07Sunderland2nd Hartlepool United
- 2005-06Reading2nd Northampton Town
- 2004-05Yeovil Town2nd Scunthorpe United
- 2003-04Doncaster Rovers2nd Hull City
- 2002-03Rushden & Diamonds2nd Hartlepool United
- 2001-02Plymouth Argyle2nd Luton Town
- 2000-01Brighton & Hove Albion2nd Cardiff City
- 1999-2000Swansea City2nd Rotherham United
- 1998-99Brentford2nd Cambridge United
- 1997-98Notts County2nd Macclesfield Town
- 1996-97Wigan Athletic2nd Fulham
- 1995-96Preston North End2nd Gillingham
- 1994-95Carlisle United2nd Walsall
- 1993-94Shrewsbury Town2nd Chester City
- 1992-93Cardiff City2nd Wrexham
Most titles
- Brentford22008-091998-99
- Carlisle United22005-061994-95
- Chesterfield22013-142010-11
- Doncaster Rovers22024-252003-04
- Notts County22009-101997-98
- Swindon Town22019-202011-12
- Accrington Stanley12017-18
- Brighton & Hove Albion12000-01
- Bromley12025-26
- Burton Albion12014-15
- Cardiff City11992-93
- Cheltenham Town12020-21
Sources: Wikipedia, API-Football