Champions by season
- 2017-18Basford United2nd Alvechurch
- 2016-17Shaw Lane2nd Witton Albion
- 2015-16Stafford Rangers2nd Shaw Lane
- 2014-15Mickleover Sports2nd Leek Town
- 2013-14Halesowen Town2nd Coalville Town
- 2012-13King's Lynn Town2nd Coalville Town
- 2011-12Grantham Town2nd Carlton Town
- 2010-11Barwell2nd Newcastle Town
- 2009-10Mickleover Sports2nd Chasetown
- 2008-09Retford United2nd Belper Town
- 2007-08Retford United2nd Cammell Laird
- 2006-07Buxton2nd Cammell Laird
- 2005-06Mossley2nd Fleetwood Town
- 2004-05North Ferriby United2nd Ilkeston Town
- 2003-04Hyde United2nd Matlock Town
- 2002-03Alfreton Town2nd Spennymoor United
- 2001-02Harrogate Town2nd Ossett Town
- 2000-01Bradford Park Avenue2nd Vauxhall Motors
Most titles
Sources: Wikipedia, API-Football