Head-to-head
- Chester6
- Darlington6
- Southport6
- Alfreton Town5
- Chorley5
- Curzon Ashton5
- Hereford FC5
- King's Lynn Town5
- Oxford City5
- Scarborough Athletic5
- South Shields5
- Brackley Town4
- Buxton4
- Kidderminster Harriers4
- Leamington4
- Marine4
- Peterborough Sports4
- Radcliffe4
- AFC Fylde3
- Bedford Town3
- Farsley Celtic3
- Macclesfield3
- Merthyr Town3
- AFC Telford United2
- Needham Market2
- Rushall Olympic2
- Scunthorpe United2
- Warrington Town2
- Worksop Town2
- Barrow1
- Bradford Park Avenue1
- Emley1
- Gateshead1
- Gloucester City1
- Guiseley1
- Harborough Town1
- Hednesford Town1
- Morecambe1
- Spalding United1
- York City1
Sources: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0), API-Football · Data sources