Head-to-head
- Hartlepool United14
- Aldershot Town12
- FC Halifax Town12
- Woking12
- Boreham Wood11
- Eastleigh11
- Bromley10
- Dagenham & Redbridge10
- Maidenhead United10
- Sutton United10
- AFC Fylde9
- Barnet9
- Gateshead9
- Wealdstone9
- Yeovil Town9
- Altrincham8
- Ebbsfleet United7
- Southend United7
- Chesterfield6
- Rochdale6
- Wrexham6
- York City6
- Barrow5
- Boston United5
- Dover Athletic5
- Torquay United5
- Braintree Town4
- Forest Green Rovers4
- Kidderminster Harriers4
- Notts County4
- Oldham Athletic4
- Stockport County4
- Tamworth4
- Carlisle United3
- Maidstone United3
- Oxford City3
- Scunthorpe United3
- Blackpool2
- Brackley Town2
- Chester2
- Dorking Wanderers2
- Guiseley2
- Harrogate Town2
- King's Lynn Town2
- Leyton Orient2
- Macclesfield Town2
- Morecambe2
- Tranmere Rovers2
- Truro City2
- Weymouth2
- Wigan Athletic2
- Chorley1
- Hitchin Town1
- Rotherham United1
- Worthing1
Sources: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0), API-Football · Data sources