Head-to-head
- Grimsby Town14
- Walsall13
- Colchester United12
- Newport County12
- Crawley Town11
- Swindon Town11
- Barrow10
- Bradford City10
- Crewe Alexandra10
- Harrogate Town10
- Tranmere Rovers10
- Cheltenham Town9
- Carlisle United8
- Gillingham8
- Doncaster Rovers7
- Mansfield Town7
- Morecambe7
- Notts County7
- Oldham Athletic7
- Port Vale7
- Shrewsbury Town7
- Accrington Stanley6
- AFC Wimbledon6
- Cambridge United6
- Chesterfield6
- Forest Green Rovers6
- Leyton Orient6
- Milton Keynes Dons6
- Stevenage6
- Stockport County6
- Fleetwood Town5
- Bromley4
- Exeter City4
- Northampton Town4
- Sutton United4
- Barnet3
- Bolton Wanderers3
- Bristol Rovers3
- Rotherham United3
- Scunthorpe United3
- Burton Albion2
- Hartlepool United2
- Leeds United2
- Macclesfield Town2
- Manchester City2
- Peterborough United2
- Plymouth Argyle2
- Rochdale2
- Southend United2
- Wrexham2
- Burnley1
- Dagenham & Redbridge1
- Derby County1
- Everton1
- Lincoln City1
- Preston North End1
Sources: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0), API-Football · Data sources