Head-to-head
- Doncaster Rovers18
- Gillingham16
- Accrington Stanley12
- Milton Keynes Dons12
- Burton Albion11
- Crewe Alexandra11
- Fleetwood Town11
- Bradford City10
- Oxford United9
- Plymouth Argyle9
- Portsmouth9
- Walsall9
- Blackpool8
- Peterborough United8
- Swindon Town8
- Wycombe Wanderers8
- Charlton Athletic7
- Ipswich Town7
- Lincoln City7
- Mansfield Town7
- Newport County7
- Northampton Town7
- Rochdale7
- Shrewsbury Town7
- Stockport County7
- Sunderland7
- Tranmere Rovers7
- Wigan Athletic7
- Barrow6
- Bolton Wanderers6
- Bristol Rovers6
- Colchester United6
- Grimsby Town6
- Harrogate Town6
- Morecambe6
- Notts County6
- Rotherham United6
- Salford City6
- Cheltenham Town5
- Barnsley4
- Bromley4
- Carlisle United4
- Coventry City4
- Crawley Town4
- Leyton Orient4
- Luton Town4
- Port Vale4
- Reading4
- Southend United4
- Stevenage4
- Sutton United4
- Cambridge United3
- Chesterfield3
- Huddersfield Town3
- Sheffield Wednesday3
- Cardiff City2
- Exeter City2
- Forest Green Rovers2
- Hartlepool United2
- Hull City2
- Scunthorpe United2
- West Ham United2
- Weymouth2
- Wrexham2
- Arsenal1
- Boreham Wood1
- Brentford1
- Chelsea1
- Dagenham & Redbridge1
- FC Halifax Town1
- Fulham1
- Gateshead1
- Guiseley1
- Haringey Borough1
- Millwall1
- Newcastle United1
Sources: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0), API-Football · Data sources