18 seasons
- 2017-18ChampionsSouth ShieldsRunner-upScarborough Athletic
- 2016-17ChampionsLancaster CityRunner-upFarsley Celtic
- 2015-16ChampionsWarrington TownRunner-upSpennymoor Town
- 2014-15ChampionsSalford CityRunner-upDarlington
- 2013-14ChampionsCurzon AshtonRunner-upDarlington
- 2012-13ChampionsSkelmersdale UnitedRunner-upCammell Laird
- 2011-12ChampionsAFC FyldeRunner-upCurzon Ashton
- 2010-11ChampionsChesterRunner-upSkelmersdale United
- 2009-10ChampionsFC Halifax TownRunner-upLancaster City
- 2008-09ChampionsDurham CityRunner-upSkelmersdale United
- 2007-08ChampionsBradford Park AvenueRunner-upFC United of Manchester
- 2006-07ChampionsBuxtonRunner-upCammell Laird
- 2005-06ChampionsMossleyRunner-upFleetwood Town
- 2004-05ChampionsNorth Ferriby UnitedRunner-upIlkeston Town
- 2003-04ChampionsHyde UnitedRunner-upMatlock Town
- 2002-03ChampionsAlfreton TownRunner-upSpennymoor United
- 2001-02ChampionsHarrogate TownRunner-upOssett Town
- 2000-01ChampionsBradford Park AvenueRunner-upVauxhall Motors
Sources: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0), API-Football · Data sources